VALLEY CITY, N.D. -- Carol Umsted got more than the word of God during services this summer at the Congregational United Church of Christ of Valley City.
She also got $50 worth of free gas. For the local farmer, it was a nice side benefit, at a time when gas was more than $4 a gallon.
Churches nationwide are making similar offers, ranging from gas card raffles to 99 cent gas sales at local stations, to boost attendance during the vacation season and attract new members.
But some Christians question whether a financial incentive should be used to draw people into church.
Robert Kruschwitz, director of The Center for Christian Ethics at Baylor University, called the promotions "unseemly" and "misguided."
Umstead, a church official, said a couple of Valley City congregants stopped attending because they considered it "a bribe." But the Rev. Carl Borden, pastor of the congregation, said the overriding goal is to have a little fun and remind people that the church is there.
"It's a method of marketing for the church," he said. "For a $200 investment we've made, we got featured in the local newspaper once, twice on TV, and it's the buzz around town. I can't get a quarter-page ad for $200."
Church leaders have debated for years whether modern marketing techniques cheapen the faith or are an effective -- and necessary -- means of evangelizing. Even those Christians who believe some marketing is helpful disagree about how far they should take the approach.
David T. Olson, director of the American Church Research Project and head of church planning for the Evangelical Covenant Church, said independent, Pentecostal and Baptist churches with nontraditional ways of attracting new members are more likely to use promotions like the gas raffles. But he said there are other more effective ways of drawing newcomers.
"I personally would encourage them that having people from their church build relationships with their friends who do not attend church, and invite them as their friend, would be a much better strategy," Olson said.
Nathan White, an Atlanta-area Baptist, was troubled by a church gas card raffle he learned about at a Baptist church in Snellville, Ga. The corporate executive, who plans to become a pastor, thinks gas giveaways are shameful financial gimmicks that undermine the Gospel.
"They are appealing to the natural corruptions in unbelieving people.... The Bible warns very explicitly about the dangers of greed, the love of money being the root of all evil," said White. "Appealing to the selfish motives of people is not Christianity."
Religion
Godly or gimmick? Churches offer free gas
- Religion
-
-
Norman church sends work, witness team to Belize
For eight days, 23 members of the Norman Community Church of the Nazarene built more than pews for a church in Belize, they also built friendships....
-
Church to participate in National Preach-In on Global Warming
Unity Church in Norman, 3001 S. Berry Road, will take part in the National Preach-In on Global Warming, from today until Sunday. The church will join more than 1,000 others participating nationwide in the third annual event, which is ...
-
The heart behind Trinity Lutheran School
Cheryl Anderson sees every day the power that education and faith can have on children. As administrator of Trinity Lutheran School and Childcare, Anderson is so passionate about the school that she is anxious to get the word out about ...
-
Holy Ascension Orthodox Christian Church plans open house Saturday
Holy Ascension Orthodox Christian Church is inviting Norman residents to an open house from 11:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. on Saturday at 3350 12th Ave. NE....
-
Church briefs
St. Joseph’s to celebrate Mardi Gras St. Joseph’s Catholic Church will host its annual Mardi Gras celebration from 6:30 to 11:30 p.m. on Feb. 18 in the parish center gymnasium, 421 E. Acres St. A New Orleans menu of pork shoulder, Cajun ...
-
Something is in the air
Reports of snow in the air are circulating as we prepare for this weekend. The weather forecasts are predicting snow by Sunday evening and our children (and their teachers) are dreaming of a snow day on Monday. Ahhhh, but something else is ...
-
Religion roundup
Church-wide garage sale Saturday St. Joseph Catholic Church will hold a church-wide garage sale from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Saturday in the Parish Center Gymnasium, 421 E. Acres St....
-
Relics of Saints to be installed at Our Lady of Lebanon
A local Catholic parish will celebrate the installation of relics on the feast day of its patron saint, Sunday....
-
Mondays can be revolutionary
Mondays are so hard, right? Ever felt the Monday morning blues? Many a song has been written about this challenging day. Who can forget the melodious voice of Karen Carpenter singing “Hangin’ around, nothing to do but frown; rainy days ...
-
What is the best way for people to live their faith?
Heart, soul, might Rabbi Mark Levin of Congregation Beth Torah, Overland Park, Kan.: Faith is the love and service of God. Deuteronomy 6:5 commands us to love God with all our “heart, soul and might.” Each person balances them differently, ...
- More Religion Headlines
-
