KANSAS CITY, Mo. — If Oklahoma falls short tonight, though it will hardly seem like it back in Norman, it won’t be the biggest upset in the history of the Big 12 championship game. It may not even be the biggest upset the Sooners have suffered at the Big 12 championship game.
It would, though, be shocking.
Perhaps the only good to come of it would be that those making the case Missouri should have simply made way for Texas (or those who think the conference should concoct a system that, should this season be repeated in the future, would make way for Texas) can now go about cooling their heels.
Yet it shouldn’t take an upset tonight to highlight the right thing. Because what you have tonight is the right thing, Oklahoma playing Missouri for the conference championship.
It’s unfortunate the Sooners and Tigers are separated by 18 spots in the BCS standings and it’s unfortunate that a 5-3 mark against league teams was enough to run away from the rest of the North Division. Also, it’s too bad the Sooners could not have reached Kansas City free of controversy.
But the source of that controversy is not how the Big 12 has gone about deciding how to determine who reaches the championship game as a result of a three-way divisional tie. The source of the controversy is the three-way divisional tie.
Think the controversy would be any more muted had a points format had been followed or, as the SEC tiebreaker would have unfolded under the same circumstances, Texas Tech would have been eliminated (more than anything on the basis of a 44-point loss to OU; which also would have served to eliminate the Sooners)?
The answer is of course it wouldn’t.
It’s a 12-team conference.
It’s impossible to play everybody.
Two divisions are therefore required.
The only way to produce two divisions given the conference’s geography, free of gerrymandering even Texas Republicans take issue with, is to divide North and South.
Bob Stoops was asked Friday about a system that put the teams with the two best records in the conference championship game.
“Then you’d have to get rid of the divisions,” he said. “I just don’t see how it would work.”
It wouldn’t work.
It couldn’t work.
In that system, had Texas taken care of Texas Tech, the Longhorns would be playing the Sooners again tonight and how would that be fair?
OU was in the same spot in 2000, having already beaten Kansas State. But the Wildcats won the North. Give the divisional structure, the matchup makes perfect sense.
Another misguided notion is the one that says the Big 12 will be revisiting its tiebreaker system. Because every time you hear it, it’s in the context of something being wrong with the tiebreaker system. Only nothing is wrong.
Selfishly, the conference went with the BCS because it figured the highest-ranked BCS team stood the best chance of delivering the conference a national championship. Selfishness aside, the BCS is in the business of determining the nation’s best teams.
On that basis, the system appears to be holding up just fine. Who wouldn’t take the Sooners over the Longhorns right now straight up?
So here we are at Arrowhead tonight. Even freezing, the place will be full. Even OU a heavy favorite, is the ABC’s prime time choice.
Not one conference coach wanted the game when it was first considered. Yet it’s been nothing but a fantastic success.
The Sooners and Tigers meet again.
Nothing wrong with that.
Clay Horning
366-3526
cfhorning@normantranscript.com
OU Sports
The right two teams are playing tonight
- OU Sports
-
-
Winning is only option
Every locker room in college basketball has the same topic floating around. It’s February. All are thinking about March Madness. Of course, some are thinking about their immediate future. Others are simply dreaming....
-
Sooners will test their mettle against country’s best at National Duals
Dual State is today....
-
Mizzou back on deck after another blowout loss to Baylor
Not again? Yes, again. For the second time this season, the Oklahoma women will have to put aside a disheartening and embarrassing loss to Baylor and get on with the rest of their season....
-
Sooners cruise past competition at Perfect 10
OKLAHOMA CITY — Compared to the rest of its schedule, Oklahoma was supposed to have a relatively easy night. Both Iowa State and Southeast Missouri are in the midst of down seasons. With little chance of losing, the fifth-ranked Sooners ...
-
Ricketts breaks record in season debut
LAS VEGAS — Well, it was going to happen. And still, it didn’t take long....
-
Schedule easing up for Sooners
For some time, the Oklahoma women have been done no favors by their schedule. That may still be the case, but not for much longer....
-
Sooners using roller-coaster season as motivation
Oklahoma’s women’s gymnastics team has been anything but consistent. After dominating its season opener, the Sooners fell to No. 7 Oregon State and No. 9 Nebraska before trouncing then-No. 2 Arkansas....
-
Sooners open season with World Series aspirations
The Sooners haven’t even taken the field yet, but there is already talk of a national championship floating around the Oklahoma locker room. The Sooners will take the first step toward that goal when they open the season at 1:15 p.m. ...
-
Sooners have to eliminate mistakes that are costing them wins
It was a typical practice for Oklahoma on Thursday. The long workout had a lot of energy and precision. It mirrored many it has had over the last three months....
-
Move to Big 12 is chance at stability
Maybe this Internet thing’s really going to make it after all. Maybe even as a news source....
- More OU Sports Headlines
-
Winning is only option
