The Norman Transcript

Opinion

July 18, 2007

Felony dog bite law seems a little harsh

State Rep. Paul Wesselhoft made headlines around the state last year when he proposed banning pit bulls -- for life. He was acting after a constituent was attacked and severely injured by a neighbor's pit bull dog.

Now, Mr. Wesselhoft, a Cleveland County Republican, wants dog owners to be charged with a felony the first time their animal seriously bites a person off their property. He wants fellow lawmakers to hear that proposal when they convene in February.

Mr. Wesselhoft's previous bills on vicious animals have been voted down. He has become a clearinghouse of sorts for pit bull bites. Pit bull owners descended on the Capitol when the breed-specific legislation came up. Where cockfighters had their champion in former Sen. Frank Shurden, pit bulls have their nemesis in Paul Wesselhoft.

Prosecutors have traditionally ignored the "first bite" and have generally filed charges after repeat attacks and warnings. The legislation allows the felony charge if a dog kills, maims or mauls on the first attack.

Convictions would be punishable by a mandatory year in prison and a $10,000 fine but fatal attacks could lead to longer sentences, the lawmaker told the Associated Press.

The legislation seems a bit harsh. We are in favor of restrictions of vicious animals no matter the breed, but often a pet can turn on a person -- even an owner -- with little notice. Pets can also be let out of yards or homes by others.

Prosecutors will have the option of filing lesser charges and that option should be pursued first. Often the fear of civil litigation is enough to force pet owners to restrict their animals.

Text Only
Opinion
  • Outhouse enthusiast’s hobby more than a relief

    Editor’s note: This previously-published column has been a reader favorite and is one of the most requested columns....

    May 27, 2012

  • Homosexuals must convince themselves, God

    Editor, The Transcript: I am not one of those in favor of same-sex anything. According to the Bible, homesexuality is a sin. Now maybe there is a new Bible out there — the homosexual Bible. I will check at Barnes & Noble....

    May 27, 2012

  • Occupy movement built on principle

    Editor, The Transcript: We the People Stand Tall! Bruce Kessler ends his letter to the editor “We the people must stand up — 8 May, 2012,” with a strong message: We the people — the very words that begin our Constitution — must work ...

    May 27, 2012

  • Parents proud of two schools’ rankings

    Editor, The Transcript: Norman parents are justifiably proud that U.S. News and World Report recently ranked Norman High School as No. 6 in our state and No. 862 in the nation and Norman North as No. 9 in the state and 1,096 in the nation ...

    May 26, 2012

  • Reducing state rates would be of minor help

    Editor, The Transcript: A Transcript editorial (May 22), in discussing the proposed reduction in income tax rates in HB 3061, states that the “trigger” mechanism is a good thing, citing the rate cut from 5.5 to 5.25 because of the 4 ...

    May 26, 2012

  • Sykes trying to secure seat

    Editor, The Transcript: By the time this reaches you, the issues surrounding HB 2440 may have been laid to rest. Based on your article of this date, let me make these observations....

    May 25, 2012

  • Fallin proposes a flawed tax-cut plan

    There was some relief in the tax-cut proposal negotiated with Gov. Mary Fallin and Republican legislative leaders, but it still calls for some difficult reductions to some necessary services....

    May 25, 2012

  • Corporate deception rules

    Editor, The Transcript: Jamie Dimon, JP Morgan Chase’s chief executive, said he does not know how the bank lost $3 billion (originally estimated at $2 billion) in a trading scheme. He called the trades “sloppy” and “stupid” but could not ...

    May 24, 2012

  • What features create a cultural center?

    The question has been raised whether an aquatic center somehow constitutes a cultural center. Although the more thorough response would be to ask, in turn, what features create a cultural center, this short treatise will simply focus on ...

    May 24, 2012

  • Keep the capitol gun-free

    Attorneys working for the state AG’s office are now able to carry handguns in their duties representing state agencies. They won’t need a concealed weapon permit. It’s the same as laws allowing U.S. attorneys, district attorneys and their ...

    May 24, 2012

The Business Marquee
Helium debate
Helium
Facebook