Editor, The Transcript:
David R. Morgan wrote "Any significant change in our health care arrangement will surely be better than what we have..." In response I quote John McEnroe: "You cannot be serious?" How can there be anyone who pays even a little attention to what's going on who does not believe that the federal government is capable of making anything worse?
I suggest a simple idea that would allow Americans to really get some good information about the proposed health care bill(s). Let's have two proponents and two who are at least generally opposed meet in a televised Q and A for at least two hours. For proponents, pick from President Barack Obama, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and Leader Harry Reid, or someone else they offer. For opponents/questioners I suggest Sen. Dr. Coburn (obvious reasons) and Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal (he's smart, articulate, calm and experienced in health care -- in case you didn't know). Some rules would be required. No opening or closing statements -- waste of time, no new information, just their old talking points. At least half the time would be devoted to questions specific to a page in the bill. Each participant would have access to a copy of the bill, preferably online, searchable, so that all would be able to read the page being questioned. The audience on television also would be shown the pertinent page(s). No audience present with the participants -- avoids useless interruption of applause or boos. An audience of a few hundred, randomly selected, would have a way of indicating their level of satisfaction with the answer being given and this indication would be on-screen in real time, but participants could not see this. The moderator would have a rubber duckie that he/she would squeeze to make repeated quacks anytime a person begins to avoid a question. OK, delete that last rule; it's just something I fantasize about when politicians are talking because it would be more fun than my best hour at Disneyland. Actually, a moderator is not needed.
If you think that the president/speaker/leader would agree to such a meeting you are more gullible than Yosemite Sam when facing the wiles of Bugs Bunny. The very fact that the proponents of the bill have not had such a session on their own proves to me that they do not want Americans to know all about the changes coming. They claim transparency, but expect the public to swallow the trillion dollar bill after viewing only through a glass darkly.
If you are a proponent of the "significant change in our health care arrangement" I dare you to contact your proponent senator or representative or president and propose such a Q and A. Be ready to be laughed at.
CHARLIE TAYLOR
Norman
Letters
No laughing matter
- Letters
-
-
More government intrusion
Editor, The Transcript: Kudos to Kathryn Jean Lopez of the National Review Online for telling it like it is (Transcript Opinion, Feb. 12, 2012) regarding President Obama’s religious “overreach.” No, Mr. President, your latest knee-jerk ...
-
It’s time for Valentine’s Day
If it’s full of hearts and flowers And a cupid with a dart, That’s a card that’s mighty pretty and aimed right for your heart....
-
Gov. Fallin’s tax plan is one big mistake
Editor, The Transcript: Well, it’s official now. In her State of the State message, Gov. Fallin confirmed that she hopes to reduce the state income tax now and totally eliminate it later. Big mistake, for two compelling reasons....
-
Another Library Vote? Good grief!
Editor, The Transcript A new library on the west side? With hardly any books? With a dumb name above the entry as shown in your rendering? Infoplace? The library bureaucracy must think Norman voters just fell off the turnip truck....
-
Eliminating state taxes places burden on poor
Editor, The Transcript: Your editorial on Feb. 8th that expressed your pleasure that the bill by Jim Wilson that would have removed the sales tax exemptions from newspapers was killed in committee was disconcerting. I can agree that the ...
-
Not time to experiment with state taxes
Editor, The Transcript Governor Fallin proposed more cuts to the state income tax in her State of the State speech Feb. 6. This comes on the heels of a House Tax Reform Task Force that also proposed phasing out the state income tax over a ...
-
Local investment is better for Norman
Editor, The Transcript Americans from all walks of life and political ideologies are asserting their voice to tell Wall Street “Enough is enough!” Occupy Norman members spoke at the Dec. 13 Norman City Council meeting, urging the city to ...
-
Decline in unions harmful to economy
Editor, The Transcript Remember sometimes you get what your ask for? Let’s see, what could that be? I know, destroy those evil unions which are compromised of the middle class....
-
Independent group needed
Editor, The Transcript: I wanted to write a letter a long time ago, but Ms. Rogers’ letter claiming that “Chromium levels in the water shouldn’t cause alarm” pushed me over the edge. As an environmental professional in Oklahoma, I have ...
-
Obamacare is socialist nightmare
Editor, The Transcript: And now for the rest of the story… “Obamacare, Another Entitlement Nightmare.” The recent St. Louis Post Dispatch editorial reprint illustrates the sophistry that characterizes the liberal mindset now grasping the ...
- More Letters Headlines
-
More government intrusion
