The Norman Transcript

Headlines

April 4, 2010

Smart meters looking pretty stupid

NORMAN — I know someone who is building a nice home in the eastern outskirts of our fair city, on a remote acreage that requires a personal visit from the local electric meter-reader person. The home sits on top of a rather steep hill and, because of locked gates and such, there is no way to get within a comfortable driving distance of the meter.

What this means is that the electric meter-reader person has to park at the bottom of the hill and hump their way up about 200 yards to be within reading range of the meter. For the current electric meter-reader, who happens to be a male of rather substantial size and weight, this monthly trek up the hill represents a considerable physical challenge. “Oh,” said he once, “that there was a better way.”

When I heard this story, I thought, “Why, of course there’s a better way! Electric meters can be read remotely from headquarters (or, at least, from a more convenient place) and meter-reader can save his strength for other,more noble tasks.”

Such is the promise of so-called “smart meters,” which our community has been targeted to receive as part of a guinea-pig project run by our local electric utility company. Perhaps you’ve seen the mailings and inserts that have accompanied your electric bill: “Aren’t smart meters great? Get one today.”

“Smart meters” are, in essence, nothing more than a small computer that plugs into the electrical wiring of your home or business, augmenting or replacing the traditional glass-enclosed meters that we are all used to seeing. The promise of smart meter technology is bright: so-called “remote metering” means that meter-reader man can leave his hiking gear at home, because electric usage can be determined from the electric utilities’ headquarters.

Other touted benefits include “load balancing,” which means that certain appliances in your home, such as refrigerators and washing machines, can be slowed down or even turned off if it is determined that they are using too much electricity at the wrong time.

In fact, electricity to your home can be completely terminated by remote control in case of tardy payment of your bill, natural disaster, or any other reason that strikes the fancy of the guy with his finger on the “off” button. You know what it’s like when your personal computer crashes. “Smart metering” means that every single house and business will have its own, individual electricity-controlling computer. What will it be like when the computer controlling all of the electricity to your house crashes? I wonder how many times the electric utility companies will have to say, “Oops, sorry; we suck. Too bad for you.”

As if that weren’t enough to give one pause, how do you like the idea of some sleazy hacker or terrorist parked near your home or place of business, using his laptop computer to wirelessly hack into all of the smart meters within range, jacking up the bills or shutting down service altogether?

Lest you think this is some crazy scene from “24,” where Jack Bauer needs to ride to the rescue and save the world, it’s not. This is real, this is now and this is the future. Google for “smart meter security” and you’ll see what I mean. Security researchers, hired by major utility companies, reported this week just how easy it is to hack into the entire “smart meter/smart grid” system and screw things up. It seems that, in their zeal to rush new money-making technology out to their customers, the electric utility companies forgot one vital thing: security.

My choice is to wait before agreeing to let the electric company slap a shiny, new smart meter on the back of my house. As with most new computer technology, I choose not to be on the “bleeding edge.” Better to let the other lemmings rush out and fall off the cliff first. Smart meter technology will get better and security will improve, but, not now; not at my house.

I know someone who is building a nice home in the eastern outskirts of our fair city, on a remote acreage that requires a personal visit from the local electric meter-reader person. The home sits on top of a rather steep hill and, because of locked gates and such, there is no way to get within a comfortable driving distance of the meter.

What this means is that the electric meter-reader person has to park at the bottom of the hill and hump their way up about 200 yards to be within reading range of the meter. For the current electric meter-reader, who happens to be a male of rather substantial size and weight, this monthly trek up the hill represents a considerable physical challenge. “Oh,” said he once, “that there was a better way.”

When I heard this story, I thought, “Why, of course there’s a better way! Electric meters can be read remotely from headquarters (or, at least, from a more convenient place) and meter-reader can save his strength for other,more noble tasks.”

Such is the promise of so-called “smart meters,” which our community has been targeted to receive as part of a guinea-pig project run by our local electric utility company. Perhaps you’ve seen the mailings and inserts that have accompanied your electric bill: “Aren’t smart meters great? Get one today.”

“Smart meters” are, in essence, nothing more than a small computer that plugs into the electrical wiring of your home or business, augmenting or replacing the traditional glass-enclosed meters that we are all used to seeing. The promise of smart meter technology is bright: so-called “remote metering” means that meter-reader man can leave his hiking gear at home, because electric usage can be determined from the electric utilities’ headquarters.

Other touted benefits include “load balancing,” which means that certain appliances in your home, such as refrigerators and washing machines, can be slowed down or even turned off if it is determined that they are using too much electricity at the wrong time.

In fact, electricity to your home can be completely terminated by remote control in case of tardy payment of your bill, natural disaster, or any other reason that strikes the fancy of the guy with his finger on the “off” button. You know what it’s like when your personal computer crashes. “Smart metering” means that every single house and business will have its own, individual electricity-controlling computer. What will it be like when the computer controlling all of the electricity to your house crashes? I wonder how many times the electric utility companies will have to say, “Oops, sorry; we suck. Too bad for you.”

As if that weren’t enough to give one pause, how do you like the idea of some sleazy hacker or terrorist parked near your home or place of business, using his laptop computer to wirelessly hack into all of the smart meters within range, jacking up the bills or shutting down service altogether?

Lest you think this is some crazy scene from “24,” where Jack Bauer needs to ride to the rescue and save the world, it’s not. This is real, this is now and this is the future. Google for “smart meter security” and you’ll see what I mean. Security researchers, hired by major utility companies, reported this week just how easy it is to hack into the entire “smart meter/smart grid” system and screw things up. It seems that, in their zeal to rush new money-making technology out to their customers, the electric utility companies forgot one vital thing: security.

My choice is to wait before agreeing to let the electric company slap a shiny, new smart meter on the back of my house. As with most new computer technology, I choose not to be on the “bleeding edge.” Better to let the other lemmings rush out and fall off the cliff first. Smart meter technology will get better and security will improve, but, not now; not at my house.

Dave Moore has been repairing computers in Norman since 1984, when he borrowed $1,200 to buy a Commodore 64 system. He can be reached at 919-9901 or www.davemoorecomputers.com.

Text Only
Headlines
  • Robinson Norman looks at transportation package to fix traffic, flooding issues

    The Robinson Street Underpass Project currently under way from Flood Avenue to Stubbeman Avenue is one project approved by Norman voters in the 2005 Bond Election. By securing funding with the bond, city staff was able to qualify for ...

    February 8, 2012 1 Photo

  • Lexington city manager resigns

    Lexington City Manager Jason Orr resigned in the city’s special council meeting Monday night, which was scheduled to discuss his employment in light of a misdemeanor charge of domestic abuse....

    February 8, 2012

  • Norman North student is finalist in statewide contest

    Norman North High School senior Joseph D’Amato is one of four finalists in the high school category for the Keep Oklahoma Beautiful’s End Litter video contest....

    February 8, 2012

  • Special zoning requested

    The Norman Planning Commission meets Thursday and will consider special zoning for Joy’s Palace and a preliminary plat for the Fountain View North addition....

    February 8, 2012

  • Senate hopefuls reach out to county Republicans

    Four men seeking the Republican nomination in Cleveland County’s Senate District 15 seat pledged Tuesday to cut taxes, eliminate unnecessary government services and open their personal tax returns....

    February 8, 2012

  • Police chief: Investigation of official ‘a bad deal all around’

    Police Chief Deana Allen has worked in Lexington for 18 years, and she likes it because it’s been calm, quiet and peaceful — at least until recently....

    February 8, 2012

  • Norman robot teams invade competition

    Two Norman area robotic teams have excelled in respective competitions, with the Sooner Norman Advanced Robotics Collaboration taking top honors and a First Lego League team, the OzBots, advancing to compete at a World Festival in April....

    February 8, 2012

  • Panel kills bill to end exemption

    A bill to end Oklahoma’s sales tax exemption for newspapers and magazines has been defeated in a Senate committee....

    February 8, 2012

  • Los Angeles district tries to restore trust in school

    LOS ANGELES — When students return to the school where two teachers were jailed last week for alleged lewdness, they’ll have new teachers in their classrooms, a new principal in the front office and new workers serving lunch....

    February 8, 2012

  • Appeals court throws out same-sex marriage ban

    SAN FRANCISCO — Same-sex marriage moved one step closer to the Supreme Court on Tuesday when a federal appeals court ruled California’s ban unconstitutional, saying it serves no purpose other than to “lessen the status and human dignity” ...

    February 8, 2012

The Business Marquee
Facebook