In the late 1960s, the newly emerging parenting experts told parents high self-esteem would lead to better grades, better behavior, and prevent drug and alcohol use.
Unfortunately, it just hasn't turned out that way. In fact, not only has research failed to establish a reliable connection between "feeling good about oneself" and either high achievement or good behavior, it also strongly suggests high self-esteem may dispose certain people -- children included -- to anti-social and?or self-destructive behavior.
As it turns out, "high self-esteem is good" is not the only example of a child-rearing myth propagated by parenting pundits.
Myth: Parents should be consistent in how they discipline their children, lest their children become "confused."
Fact: Parents need to be consistent in what they discipline for, but not in how they discipline. More important than the method is the message and the same disciplinary message can be sent in numerous ways.
Let's say a 9-year-old has a full-blown public outburst because his parents refuse to buy him a toy he sees in a store. His parents could take him home and confine him to his room for the rest of the day. The next time a public tantrum occurs, it would be perfectly OK for them to make him cancel a weekend sleepover at a friend's house.
The point is every time this child throws a public tantrum, he needs to pay a price. The nature of the price, however, can vary from situation to situation. That policy does not confuse consistency with predictability.
Myth: Parents need to discipline immediately after the occurrence of misbehavior, or the child in question may not be able, later, to connect the misbehavior and the consequence.
Fact: This certainly is true as regards toddlers, but once a child develops long-term memory -- this usually occurs around age 31?2 -- consequences for misbehavior can be delayed accordingly. The fact is, it's often impossible to come up with a suitable consequence at the moment misbehavior occurs. Not a problem.
An older 3-year-old still can connect the consequence with the misbehavior if the consequence is delayed as much as a day. By age 5, a child easily can relate to a delay of upwards of a week. And as for a teenager, well, the sky's the limit.
Let's say Bonzo, age 17 going on 2, comes home obviously inebriated one January night. Let me assure you, he definitely will be able to make the connection between that not-so-little indiscretion and not going to the beach with his friends over spring break, even if his parents do not so inform him for weeks.
Myth: Most misbehavior simply should be ignored, as giving it attention of any kind is likely to perpetuate it.
Fact: Again, this is true of toddlers. After all, it's not reasonable to expect a 2-year-old to know public tantrums are a social faux pas.
So, when a tantrum occurs, you take said toddler to a relatively private place and ignore his screams until they go away. On the other hand, a 3-year-old who throws a tantrum in a store needs to be taken home without that toy he was looking forward to.
In most cases, a child who misbehaves needs to be punished. Not always, mind you, because in some cases, especially if the misbehavior in question is not recurrent, just a stern look accompanied, perhaps, by a few equally stern words will do the trick.
But for a misbehavior that occurs frequently, or in the case of something really outrageous, punishment is the order of the day. In either situation, the child needs to get the message that the wrongdoing will not, under any circumstances, be tolerated.
What's the best way to punish? Take away valuable freedom and?or privilege.
In that regard, something as simple as sending a child to his?her room for an hour, or even the rest of the day, generally is very effective.
Family psychologist John Rosemond answers parents' questions and includes his speaking schedule on his Web site at www.rosemond.com.
Features
Myths and facts of raising good citizens
- Features
-
-
‘Polar Plunge’ to benefit Special Olympics Oklahoma athletes
On Saturday, hearty individuals will plunge into a freezing pool of water at Marc Heitz Chevrolet in Norman for the 11th annual Polar Plunge benefiting Special Olympics Oklahoma. Registration begins at 9 a.m., the bus pull competition ...
-
Local 4-H member Morrow recognized for volunteer service
Emily Morrow, 18, of Norman has been honored for her volunteer service with a state-level Certificate of Excellence from the 2012 Prudential Spirit of Community Awards program, and also received a President’s Volunteer Service Award from ...
-
Anna Myers to speak Saturday
Anna Myers will be the guest speaker for the Oklahoma City Writers’ Inc. monthly program on Saturday....
-
Veteran’s Corner recognizes volunteer Dick Clark this week
Our volunteer of the week is a Marine who served in Vietnam. Today we are recognizing Dick Clark of Norman for his volunteer service helping the nation’s heroes to obtain the VA benefits that they are eligible for. His wife, Donna, has ...
-
Norman Public Library to host eighth annual Crowns Tea
A Black History Month tradition is making its annual return to the Norman Public Library....
-
A fix for gumbo fans with Aunt Helen Rose’s Chicken Gumbo
My husband always talks longingly about his Aunt Helen Rose’s Chicken Gumbo. I mentioned to her that I wish I could make her famous dish, but it takes too long, so she sent me this quick version. My husband’s verdict is that it’s great....
-
Tips on preventing, detecting and reporting elder abuse
Dear Savvy Senior, Can you write a column on the shameful crime of elder abuse? I’ve worked for Adult Protective Services for many years, and it seems like this ongoing problem doesn’t get enough attention. Concerned Citizen Dear ...
-
The mother daughter trip of a lifetime
It was time for an adventure. The year of planning was our daughter Shanna’s job. I was just along for the ride. I guess my job was to stay in shape and be ready for what was to come. Fortunately, when I retired, I was determined to ...
-
Lexington Opry to perform Feb. 24
The next Lexington Opry Show will be from 6 to 9 p.m. Feb. 24 at the Les Chandler Center in Lexington....
-
It’s a matter of growing up, one step at a time
Life has a funny way of telling you to just get over it and grow up....
- More Features Headlines
-
‘Polar Plunge’ to benefit Special Olympics Oklahoma athletes






