The Norman Transcript

Education

Discussion

October 9, 2012

Outcry prompts review

By Caitlin Schudalla The Norman Transcript

NORMAN — Schools not satisfied with grading system

The State Department of Education, set to release their controversial letter grades for school evaluation Monday, postponed the release after their official acceptance was unanimously tabled by the State Board of Education.

Due to widespread outcry questioning the system’s formulas, board members overstepped the department’s plan by opting to wait and review these aspects until the full board meeting Oct. 25.

“The board voted 6-0 to postpone the release due to the amount of concern expressed by educators across the state, particularly regarding the formula’s measurement of growth in student performance,” said Shelly Hickman, Norman Public Schools community relations coordinator. “The state board wished to review the formula prior to their next meeting to address these concerns.”

The state’s new report card-style evaluation system was approved by the legislature in 2011 and is intended to replace the Academic Performance Index as Oklahoma’s means of tracking school performance and improvement.

Met with statewide unease and disapproval, the system’s formula has drawn more than 150 superintendents’ outspoken concerns and 300 districts’ request for further review, NPS Superintendent Joe Siano said.

“We are grateful the State Board of Education has chosen to take the time to study the method the State Department of Education is using to calculate grades for schools,” Siano said.

Reiterating his particular concerns with the system, Siano added, “We would like the board to investigate our concerns, which are a) the system does not accurately calculate student growth — that is, students who score proficient on the third-grade test and then score at the same level of proficiency on the fourth-grade test are not considered to have grown by the SDE; b) it does not treat all students’ achievement the same but rather weights the scores of at-risk subgroups and minimizes the impact of students scoring at proficient and advanced; and c) it is not a traditional A-F scale familiar to parents, e.g. 90-100 is not an A in the SDE’s formula.”

In spite of the state’s postponement, the Norman Board of Education will have a special meeting 5 p.m. today in the Norman High School Conference Center to discuss the grades given to Norman schools and take an in-depth look at the formula as it currently stands.

“It is important that the new school accountability system that we all embrace better evaluates and reflects the quality of instruction in our schools as it was intended to by the legislature,” Siano said.

Caitlin Schudalla366-3541cschudalla@normantranscript.com

For local news and more, subscribe to The Norman Transcript Smart Edition, or our print edition.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Education
  • Board looks at hirings

    The hiring of three key administrators tops Monday’s meeting of the Norman Public Schools board of education. The board meets at 7 p.m. in the Norman City Council chambers, 201 W. Gray St....

    May 20, 2013

  • Technology center board meets

    Weapons policy updates, state funding and a five-year strategic plan were the topics of note at the Moore Norman Technology Center Board meeting Thursday evening....

    May 17, 2013

  • Noble High School students present projects at mock trade show

    Noble High School juniors and seniors in Roger Clement’s Chemistry II class got a special preview of what professional chemistry and engineering would be like as they presented the fruit of semester-long projects in a mock trade show ...

    May 17, 2013

  • School Food Pantry Teachers, staff of Norman Public Schools work to combat hunger

    For the vast majority of Norman’s chronically hungry children, all that stands between them and the food they need is the awareness of those around them....

    May 16, 2013 1 Photo

  • Bart Conner Gym recognized for being champion in education

    The Norman Chamber of Commerce went a step further Tuesday in its mission of facilitating a partnership between local public schools and businesses by designating the Bart Conner Gymnastics Academy as its first Champion in Education....

    May 15, 2013

  • Teacher set to retire after nearly four decades

    Norman North High School English teacher Claudia Swisher has been at the front of a classroom on the first day of school 39 times, and each of those days has consistently been followed by a night of little sleep....

    May 12, 2013

  • Norman students named scholarship winners

    National Merit Scholarship Corporation (NMSC) announced this year’s National Merit $2,500 scholarship winners, with five Norman students among Oklahoma’s scholars....

    May 8, 2013

  • Rose State president Terry Britton gives farewell commencement

    Rose State College President Terry Britton, whose career at the college spans more than 40 years, will deliver his “farewell commencement” speech before graduates at 7 p.m. Friday....

    May 8, 2013

  • NPS raising cost of lunches by $0.05 per meal

    Norman Public Schools’ lunches will see a slight increase in cost following a measure approved Monday evening by the Board of Education....

    May 7, 2013

  • Norman North HS band congratulated by state senators

    The Norman North High School Band will be honored with a citation in the State Senate Chambers at 1 p.m. today to begin their official fundraising efforts to be a featured band Dec. 7 at the Pearl Harbor Memorial Parade in Hawaii....

    May 7, 2013