The Norman Transcript

Editorials

January 27, 2007

Creating a cooperative climate

WASHINGTON -- Despite the raging controversy over Iraq military policy, President Bush's plea for bipartisan cooperation on the domestic agenda has a chance of success in the Senate. The reason has less to do with sympathy for the politically weakened chief executive than a dynamic that has gone largely unnoticed among the senators themselves.

Since the midterm election created a near-even balance in the Senate -- 51 Democrats and 49 Republicans -- serious efforts at cross-party communication have developed significant momentum.

Forty senators showed up on Jan. 9 for the first of a planned series of weekly 8 a.m. breakfasts, designed to provide neutral ground where lawmakers of both parties can meet together rather than caucus separately.

On Wednesday, some 60 top Senate staffers of both parties held a similar breakfast session, aimed at obliterating party lines and fostering personal relationships.

The core group of the Gang of 14 -- the self-selected bipartisan caucus that negotiated the compromise on judicial filibusters and averted an explosion in the Senate -- has reconstituted itself as a "fire department" ready to douse other blazes.

At the top, Majority Leader Harry Reid and Minority Leader Mitch McConnell have forged a personal relationship of unusual trust, and already have used it to rescue landmark ethics legislation from threatened defeat and steer it to overwhelming passage.

All this has happened in the first weeks of a session that saw the Senate forced to adjust to a sudden shift of party control from Republicans to Democrats. No comparable spirit has developed in the House of Representatives, where the new Republican minority is complaining bitterly that dissenting views have been stifled.

And there is no guarantee that the budding spirit of good fellowship among senators will survive the Iraq debates and persist into the spring and summer, when other big issues reach the point of decision. But as Bush suggested in his State of the Union address, at least some issues -- education, immigration, health care, energy and the environment -- are open to bipartisan approaches.

The powerful current toward consensus-building flowing through the Senate has two sources. Politicians who were at home last autumn had their ears burned by constituents frustrated by the partisanship of the last Congress and its failure to act on issues of national concern. "The last election was a resounding repudiation of the status quo," said Sen. Olympia Snowe of Maine, one of the few Republican survivors in New England.

And senators themselves are weary of excessive partisanship. "All our time is spent in team meetings, playing petty kindergarten games about what we're going to do to each other," said Republican Sen. Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, referring to the party caucuses.

Snowe and Alexander became ringleaders in two of the efforts to break down party barriers. Alexander teamed with Sen. Joe Lieberman of Connecticut, re-elected as an independent Democrat, as co-hosts of the new weekly Tuesday morning breakfasts for senators of both parties.

With senators seated at round tables of eight, and the seats alternating between Republicans and Democrats, the breakfasts feature five-minute briefings by a pair of senators from opposite parties on an issue about to reach the floor, followed by 20 minutes of discussion of that issue and a half-hour of general conversation. No votes are taken; no policy set. But senators, without staff, get to listen to each other and build personal bonds.

After skipping a week for the Martin Luther King holiday, the second such breakfast was held on Tuesday and 24 senators showed up, even though they were not expected to return to Congress until that night's State of the Union address. Lieberman and Alexander are hopeful the weekly breakfasts will become a staple on senators' calendars.

At the head of the reinvigorated core group of the Gang of 14 are Snowe and Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu of Louisiana. They have no fixed meeting schedule but a readiness to intervene if the opposing parties seem headed for gridlock.

Landrieu explained her motivation: "The success of the Gang of 14 was not just a success for the Senate. It was also a very personally rewarding experience. We met for rather long periods, with no staff allowed, and literally talked and listened very quietly. That experience changed me; it made me think we need to do this more often -- find a quiet time and use it to search for common ground."

The two efforts are complementary -- not in competition. The Snowe-Landrieu Common Ground group will work on policy; the Lieberman-Alexander breakfasts are primarily social. But Lieberman expressed the hope of all the organizers when he said, "We're trying to change the atmosphere here and make agreement a little easier to come by."

David Broder writes for the Washington Post Writers Group. His e-mail address is davidbroder@washpost.com.

Text Only
Editorials
  • War on terrorism isn’t over yet

    Weary of a war on terror that has gone on for years, we would like to declare victory and return to normalcy. Last month, a mini-storm erupted when an Obama administration official was said to have told a writer, “The war on terror is ...

    May 22, 2012

  • ‘Treading water gets us no closer to shore’

    Today may be decision day for the Oklahoma House of Representatives. A vote on House Bill 3061, which lowers the state’s income tax rate from 5.25 percent to 4.8 percent, is expected to be voted on in the House....

    May 22, 2012

  • Other cost of imprisonment

    A decision by the Texas Supreme Court to award more than $2 million to a former inmate who was released from prison after 26 years will empower the dozens of ongoing innocence projects....

    May 22, 2012

  • Is it worth $35 million plus to watch dull conventions?

    We don’t often find ourselves in agreement with Oklahoma Sen. Tom Coburn. But his request for the political parties to refund millions of dollars set aside for the political conventions this summer is starting to make sense....

    May 20, 2012

  • Enthusiasm for the arts

    The handful of annual concerts, festivals and special arts events that make Norman special begin today with the Luncheon on the Grass. It’s a collaboration of OU, the Firehouse, the Jacobson House, the Norman Arts Council and the ...

    May 20, 2012

  • More workers now on the job

    Unemployment rates have fallen in two thirds of all U.S. states, providing evidence that economic growth is boosting hiring....

    May 19, 2012

  • The first ozone alert day

    The first Ozone Alert Day of the year was Friday. It fell, coincidentally, with the national Bike to Work Day. CART buses allowed free ridership....

    May 19, 2012

  • Ride a bike to work today

    Attention all cyclists: Today is the day to dust off that bicycle hanging from the garage rafters, pump up the tires, strap on a helmet and cruise to work. The problem is many of our residents travel to Oklahoma City each morning. Some ...

    May 18, 2012

  • Nominee deserves a yes or no vote

    Oklahomans who volunteer to serve on state boards donate many hours of service. They often are professionals whose expertise and advice would cost the state thousands of dollars if agencies had to seek such counsel on their own....

    May 18, 2012

  • Expect fewer deputies

    Residents in the rural parts of Cleveland County have grown accustomed to seeing more sheriff’s cruisers patrol their streets. The increased presence over the past few years has pushed criminals down the road and slowed down cars on ...

    May 17, 2012

The Business Marquee
Facebook